A coin rotation paradox calculator shows how many times a coin turns as it rolls once around another. The surprising answer is that a coin rolling around an identical coin makes two full turns, not one. Enter the two radii and the calculator gives the number of rotations for a roll around the outside of a circle, around the inside of a larger circle, or around the outside of any closed curve of a known length. The result follows the Wikipedia page on the coin rotation paradox, and the work is done in your browser.
How to use the coin rotation paradox calculator
- Choose the path: outside a circle, inside a circle, or around a closed curve.
- Enter the radius of the rolling coin and the radius of the fixed circle, or the length of the curve.
- Press Calculate.
The paradox
If you roll a coin around the edge of an identical coin, without slipping, the coin makes two full rotations by the time it returns to its starting point, even though its edge touches only a path equal to its own circumference. The Wikipedia page states that the rolling coin makes two rotations. Many people expect one, since the distance along the edge of the fixed coin equals one circumference of the rolling coin. The extra turn comes from the fact that the coin also goes around the fixed coin, which adds a rotation of its own.
The formula
For a coin of radius r rolling around the outside of a fixed circle of radius R, the page gives the number of rotations as R/r + 1. For equal coins, that is 1 + 1, which is 2. For a fixed circle three times as large as the rolling coin, it is 3 + 1, which is 4, as on the page. The reason is that the center of the rolling coin travels along a circle of radius R + r, which is a distance of 2π(R + r). Dividing by the circumference 2πr of the coin gives (R + r)/r, which equals R/r + 1. The calculator shows the rotations from the rolling alone, R/r, and the extra rotation of 1.
Rolling around the inside
When a coin rolls around the inside of a larger circle, its center travels along a circle of radius R − r, so the number of rotations is (R − r)/r, which is R/r − 1. The same reasoning applies, but the extra turn now goes the other way and subtracts one. If the fixed circle has twice the radius of the coin, the coin makes exactly one rotation. This is the inside case, which comes from the same argument about the path of the center and is not stated on the page. The calculator reports it as R/r minus 1.
Rolling around other shapes
The page also covers shapes that are not circles. For a closed curve, the rolling coin makes the number of rotations given by the length of the curve divided by the coin's circumference, plus one extra rotation. A curve of length 2π with a coin of radius 1 gives 1 + 1, which is 2, matching the case of equal circles. Enter the perimeter of the curve and the coin's radius in the closed-curve option. A square with a side of 10 and a coin of radius 0.5 would give 40 divided by π, plus 1, or about 13.73 turns.
Why the extra turn appears
Count the turns by watching a mark on the coin. As the coin rolls along the fixed edge, the mark turns once for every circumference of distance rolled. But while it rolls, the coin is also carried around the fixed coin through a full 360 degrees, and this turning of the whole coin is the extra rotation. Another way to see it is with the center of the coin, which makes one trip around a bigger circle. The rotation of the coin as seen from outside is the sum of the rolling and of the trip around.
A worked example
Take a rolling coin of radius 2 and a fixed circle of radius 5. The coin rolls without slipping once around the outside. The rolling alone gives 5/2, which is 2.5 rotations, and the extra rotation adds 1, for a total of 3.5 rotations, or 1,260 degrees. The center of the coin moves along a circle of radius 7, a distance of 2π × 7, which is 43.9823. Dividing that distance by the coin's circumference, 2π × 2, gives 3.5, in agreement. You can enter 2 and 5 to check these numbers.
Typing tips
Use the same unit for both radii and for the curve length. The result does not depend on the unit, since it is a ratio. Enter the radii of the circles, not their diameters, and leave the box for the curve length empty unless you chose the closed-curve option.
Common mistakes
- Forgetting the extra turn. The answer is R/r + 1, not R/r.
- Using the diameter instead of the radius. The formulas use the radii.
- Applying the outside formula inside. Inside, subtract one.
- Counting slipping. The result assumes rolling without slipping.
- Taking the path of the edge as the path of the center. The center goes around a larger circle.
What next
Use this often? Add Coin Rotatio to your Home screen.
Frequently asked questions
What is the coin rotation paradox calculator?
A tool for the coin rotation paradox: a coin rolling around an identical coin makes two full rotations, not one, even though its edge rolls only one circumference.
What is the formula for rotations?
R/r + 1 for a coin of radius r rolling around the outside of a circle of radius R. For R = 3r it is 4.
What is the formula for rolling inside a circle?
(R − r)/r, which is R/r − 1. A coin rolling inside a circle of twice its radius turns once.
Why is there an extra rotation?
The center of the coin travels around a circle of radius R + r, and the coin also turns once as it is carried around.
What if the fixed shape is not a circle?
For a closed curve, the coin makes L/(2πr) rotations from the rolling, plus one extra.
Sources
Was this tool helpful?
What went wrong?
We only receive the reason you pick, never what you typed into the tool.
Thanks for your feedback.