A potato paradox calculator shows how much a mass of potatoes, or any other wet food, shrinks when its water content falls by a small percentage. Enter the starting mass, the starting water percentage and the new water percentage, and it gives the new mass.
How to use the potato paradox calculator
- Choose US or metric units.
- Enter the starting total mass.
- Enter the starting water content and the new water content as percentages.
- Press Calculate.
The paradox
The classic puzzle starts with 100 kilograms of potatoes that are 99 percent water. They are left to dry until they are 98 percent water. How much do they weigh? Most people guess about 99 kilograms. The true answer is 50 kilograms [1]. A change of one percentage point in the water content halves the mass, which is why it is called a paradox.
The dry mass does not change
The key idea is that only the water leaves. The dry mass stays the same [1]. In the example, 99 percent of 100 kilograms is water, so the dry matter is 1 kilogram. After drying, that 1 kilogram is 2 percent of the new total, as the water is now 98 percent. This can be written as (2 ÷ 100) × x = 1, so x = 100 ÷ 2 = 50 kilograms.
The general formula
The general form here is our own working from the example. The dry mass is the starting mass times one minus the starting water fraction. The new total mass is the dry mass divided by one minus the new water fraction. The new water mass is the new total minus the dry mass. For 100 kilograms, 99 percent and 98 percent, these give 1, 50 and 49 kilograms.
A second example
Take 8 kilograms of potatoes at 98 percent water. The dry matter is 8 × 0.02 = 0.16 kilograms, and the water is 7.84 kilograms. If the water content falls to 95 percent, the new total is 0.16 ÷ 0.05 = 3.2 kilograms, which contains 3.04 kilograms of water. The calculator reproduces these numbers, so you can use it to check them or to try your own values.
Why a small change matters
The water percentage hides the real change. Going from 99 to 98 percent water means that the dry matter doubles its share of the total, from 1 percent to 2 percent. As the dry mass does not change, the total must halve. In general, the new mass is the old mass times the ratio of the two dry fractions, so a change from 99 to 98 percent has a far greater effect than a change from 50 to 49 percent.
US and metric units
The classic puzzle gives its masses in kilograms [1]. The ratio of the masses does not depend on the unit, so any mass unit gives the same answer. The calculator has a US option in pounds and a metric option in kilograms. With US units, a starting mass of 200 pounds at 99 percent water gives a new mass of 100 pounds at 98 percent. The percentages are the same in both modes.
If the water content goes up
The classic puzzle does not discuss a rise in the water content. If the new percentage is higher than the starting one, the formula still works: the same dry matter now carries more water, and the total mass grows. This might describe food that is soaked or rehydrated. The calculator says that water has been gained in that case, and this note is our own. For example, 10 pounds at 90 percent water becomes 20 pounds at 95 percent.
Dried fruit
The same reasoning applies to dried fruit, although the puzzle gives no numbers for it. The calculator works for any food or material for which you know the water content before and after. The values come from your own measurements or from the packaging. The figure of 99 percent in the puzzle is chosen to make the result surprising, and real potatoes and fruits have their own water contents.
The limits of the model
The model assumes that nothing but water is lost, so the dry matter stays constant, and that the percentages are by mass. In real drying, some volatile compounds may also escape, and the percentages are only as accurate as the measurements. The result is a good estimate for a puzzle or a quick calculation, but it is not a substitute for weighing the food after it has dried.
A quick check by ratio
There is a shortcut that you can use to check any result. The new mass equals the old mass times the starting dry percentage divided by the new dry percentage, where the dry percentage is 100 minus the water percentage. This is our own working from the same idea, and it is not stated in the source. For 100 kilograms going from 99 to 98 percent water, it is 100 × 1 ÷ 2 = 50 kilograms. For 8 kilograms going from 98 to 95 percent, it is 8 × 2 ÷ 5 = 3.2 kilograms.
Planning a batch of dried food
You can also use the tool the other way round, to plan how much dried food a batch will give. As an example of our own, 10 pounds of fruit at 80 percent water has 2 pounds of dry matter. Dried to 20 percent water, it weighs 2 ÷ 0.8 = 2.5 pounds. The same reasoning holds for dried fruit, but the figures here are our own and depend on the water contents that you measure for your food.
Common mistakes
- Treating the percentage as a part of the starting mass. The dry mass is what stays the same.
- Entering 0.98 instead of 98. Enter percentages from 0 to 99.99.
- Expecting the mass to fall by the same percentage. It depends on the dry fractions.
- Forgetting that the new total includes water. Total = dry matter plus water.
What next
Use this often? Add Potato Parad to your Home screen.
Frequently asked questions
What is a potato paradox calculator?
A tool that finds the new mass of a food when its water content changes, using the fact that the dry mass stays the same.
What is the potato paradox?
100 kg of potatoes that are 99 percent water, dried to 98 percent water, weigh 50 kg, not 99 kg.
How do you work out the new mass?
Divide the dry mass by one minus the new water fraction.
Does the calculator work for dried fruit?
Yes, for any food where you know the water content before and after.
What if the new water content is higher?
The total grows, and the calculator reports water gained.
Sources
Was this tool helpful?
What went wrong?
We only receive the reason you pick, never what you typed into the tool.
Thanks for your feedback.