Saved

Press the star next to a tool's name to save it.

All my tools

Traditional vs Roth IRA Calculator

Use this traditional vs roth ira calculator to compare what each account leaves you after tax. Enter the yearly amount, years, return and your tax rate now and in retirement.

Restored your last values ·

years
%
%
%

Enter the money you would set aside each year before tax, how many years it stays invested, the yearly return you expect, your tax rate today and the rate you expect in retirement. The calculator compares what each account leaves you after tax.

Everything is worked out in your browser. Nothing you type is sent anywhere.

–

–

Enter the yearly amount, the years, the return and your two tax rates, then press Calculate.

See full result

This traditional vs roth ira calculator shows which account leaves you more money to spend in retirement. Enter what you would set aside each year before tax, how long it stays invested, the return you expect and two tax rates: the one you pay today and the one you expect to pay when you take the money out. The answer comes down to those two rates, and the calculator shows you by how much.

Both accounts let savings grow without yearly tax on the gains. The difference is when the tax is paid. With a traditional IRA you may deduct your contributions if you qualify, and the deductible contributions and earnings you withdraw later are taxable [1]. With a Roth IRA your contributions are not deductible, but a qualified distribution carries no tax at all [1]. So one account taxes the money on the way out, the other on the way in.

How to compare traditional vs roth ira accounts

  1. Enter the yearly amount before tax, for example 7,000 dollars.
  2. Enter the years until you will use the money, such as 30.
  3. Enter a yearly return you think is realistic, for example 6%.
  4. Enter your tax rate today and the rate you expect in retirement.
  5. Press Calculate to see both after-tax values and the difference.

How the comparison works

The calculator gives both accounts the same budget of pre-tax money, which is the fair way to compare them. In the traditional IRA the whole amount goes in each year. In the Roth IRA, tax at today’s rate is paid first, so a smaller amount goes in. Both then grow at the same return. Our own working for the value of yearly deposits is: amount × ((1 + return) to the power of the years − 1) ÷ return.

At the end, the traditional balance is taxed at your retirement rate, while the Roth balance comes out tax-free. Written out, the traditional IRA leaves the grown value × (1 − retirement rate) and the Roth leaves the grown value × (1 − today’s rate). That is why the account with the lower tax rate wins: if you expect a lower rate in retirement, the traditional IRA comes out ahead; if you expect a higher one, the Roth does; and if the two rates are equal, they leave exactly the same amount.

Worked example

Say you can set aside 7,000 dollars a year before tax for 30 years at 6%. Grown, that is about 553,400 dollars. You pay 22% today and expect 12% in retirement. The traditional IRA leaves 553,400 × 0.88, about 487,000 dollars. The Roth leaves 553,400 × 0.78, about 431,700 dollars, because only 5,460 dollars a year went in after tax. The traditional IRA wins by about 55,300 dollars. Swap the two rates and the Roth wins by the same amount.

Tax rate todayTax rate in retirementWhich leaves more
22%12%Traditional IRA
12%22%Roth IRA
22%22%The same

The 2026 contribution limits

For 2026 the IRA contribution limit is 7,500 dollars, and people aged 50 and over can add a catch-up of 1,100 dollars [2]. The limit covers traditional and Roth IRAs together, so you cannot put 7,500 dollars into each. If the amount you enter is above the limit, the calculator says so, because the extra would have to be saved somewhere else.

Roth IRA contributions are also limited by income. For 2026 the amount you can put in phases out between 153,000 and 168,000 dollars of income for single filers and heads of household, and between 242,000 and 252,000 dollars for married couples filing jointly [2]. Above the top of the range you cannot contribute to a Roth IRA directly.

Other differences worth knowing

  • Required minimum distributions. A traditional IRA has required withdrawals once you reach the age the rules set, while a Roth IRA has none for the original owner [1].
  • Early withdrawals. Taking money out of a traditional IRA before age 59½ can bring a 10% additional tax as well as income tax [1].
  • Deductibility. Whether a traditional contribution is deductible depends on your income and on whether you have a workplace plan [1].

Choosing your tax rates

The rates that matter are the ones on the last dollars you earn now and on the dollars you will withdraw later, including any state tax. Nobody knows future tax rates, so try a few: your rate today, a lower one if you expect a smaller income in retirement, and a higher one if you expect large pensions, required withdrawals or tax changes. If the answer flips between them, splitting your savings between both accounts is a common way to hedge.

Why the same budget matters

A common shortcut is to compare 7,000 dollars in a Roth IRA with 7,000 dollars in a traditional IRA. That is not a fair test, because the Roth dollars have already been taxed and the traditional dollars have not. Putting 7,000 dollars of after-tax money into a Roth costs more of your paycheck than putting 7,000 dollars into a traditional IRA. Starting both from the same pre-tax amount, as this calculator does, removes that bias and shows the real effect of the two tax rates.

In real life you might also invest the tax saved by a traditional contribution in a normal taxable account. The calculator does not model that extra account, so treat it as a clean comparison of the two IRAs on their own.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing 7,000 dollars in each account instead of the same pre-tax budget. That makes the Roth look better than it is.
  • Using your average tax rate instead of your marginal rate.
  • Forgetting state income tax in either rate.
  • Ignoring the yearly IRA limit, which covers both account types together.

For a projection of one account, use our Roth IRA calculator or the 401(k) calculator.

What next

Use this often? Add Traditional to your Home screen.

Frequently asked questions

Which wins in a traditional vs roth ira comparison?

With the same pre-tax budget, the account with the lower tax rate wins: traditional if your rate in retirement is lower than today, Roth if it is higher, and they tie if the rates are equal.

What is the 2026 IRA contribution limit?

It is 7,500 dollars, plus a 1,100 dollar catch-up for people aged 50 and over, across traditional and Roth IRAs together.

Are Roth IRA withdrawals tax-free?

A qualified distribution from a Roth IRA is tax-free. Other withdrawals may be partly taxable.

Why does the Roth put in less each year?

Roth contributions are made with money that has already been taxed, so from the same pre-tax budget a smaller amount goes in.

What went wrong?

We only receive the reason you pick, never what you typed into the tool.

Thanks for your feedback.

More Finance Tools