An RRSP vs TFSA calculator compares putting money in a registered retirement savings plan with putting it in a tax-free savings account. Enter your tax rate now, the rate you expect when you withdraw, the return and the years, and this one shows what each route is worth after tax. It also shows the tax refund and checks the amounts against the 2026 limits.
How to use the RRSP vs TFSA calculator
- Pick what happens to the RRSP tax refund: put it in a TFSA or spend it.
- Enter the amount you put in the RRSP and the number of years.
- Enter your marginal tax rate now, the rate you expect when you withdraw and the yearly return.
- Press Calculate and read which route ends ahead and by how much.
The idea behind the comparison
An RRSP gives a deduction when you put money in and taxes the money when you take it out. A TFSA gives no deduction and no tax on withdrawal. The Canada Revenue Agency says that RRSP contributions can be deducted up to your limit, and that the amount you withdraw has to be included in your income for the year [3]. It also says that TFSA contributions are not deductible, while interest, dividends and capital gains are generally tax-free, even when withdrawn [4].
The formulas we use
The pages give the rules but no comparison formula, so the working here is our own. Let k be the growth factor, one plus the yearly return raised to the number of years. The RRSP is worth the amount times k times one minus your tax rate on withdrawal. The refund is the amount times your tax rate now. A TFSA of a given size is worth that size times k, because nothing is taken out.
A worked example
Take $10,000 at a marginal rate of 30 percent now and 20 percent on withdrawal, with a return of 5 percent for 25 years. The growth factor is 3.386355. The RRSP is worth $27,090.84 after tax. The refund is $3,000, and grown in a TFSA for 25 years it is worth $10,159.06. The RRSP route is therefore worth $37,249.90. A TFSA holding the same $10,000 is worth $33,863.55, so the RRSP route ends ahead by $3,386.35.
If you spend the refund
The second choice compares the same net cost. The RRSP route costs $10,000 less the $3,000 refund, and the TFSA route puts in that same $7,000. After 25 years the RRSP leaves $27,090.84 after tax, and the $7,000 TFSA is worth $23,704.48. The gap is again $3,386.35. In both choices the gap equals the amount times the growth factor times the difference between your two tax rates.
The simple rule
Because of that gap formula, the RRSP route ends ahead when your tax rate on withdrawal is lower than your rate now, the two tie when the rates are equal and the TFSA route ends ahead when the rate on withdrawal is higher. The return and the number of years change the size of the gap, not who is ahead. This is the main lesson, and the calculator spells it out in the result.
The 2026 limits
The CRA limits page lists the RRSP dollar limit for 2026 as $33,810 and the TFSA dollar limit as $7,000 [1]. Another CRA page says the RRSP limit is the lesser of 18 percent of the previous year's earned income and the annual limit [2]. If the amounts you enter are above those figures, the calculator adds a warning. Your own room is on your notice of assessment and in My Account, and room carries forward, so the warning is only a prompt to check.
Getting TFSA room back
The CRA page on withdrawing from a TFSA says that the amount you withdraw is added back to your room on January 1 of the next calendar year [5]. This calculator does not model withdrawals from a TFSA before the end of the period, but the rule matters if you plan to take money out and put it back.
Assumptions you should know
The tool uses one flat marginal rate now and one on withdrawal. It assumes the same return in both accounts, contributions at the start of the period and a single withdrawal at the end. Real life has tax brackets, provincial credits, clawbacks of income-tested benefits and withdrawals spread over many years. Those make the true answer more complex, which is why the output is an estimate.
Figures that change
The two dollar limits are for 2026 and are kept in a single block with the year. The 2026 RRSP limit is the figure on a page dated October 2026 and the next one will be higher. The comparison itself does not depend on the year.
What the calculator leaves out
It does not model a spousal RRSP, unused room from earlier years, the Home Buyers' Plan, withdrawals before retirement or the tax withheld at source on an RRSP withdrawal, which is only a prepayment. It does not tell you which account suits you. Use it to see the trade-off in numbers and take the result to a tax professional.
Common mistakes
- Using your average rate. Use the marginal rate, the tax on your next dollar.
- Comparing unequal costs. Use the same cost for both routes, as the two choices do.
- Ignoring room. Check the limits and your own room before contributing.
- Treating a tie as a reason to skip one account. Other rules may favour one of them.
What next
Use this often? Add RRSP vs TFSA to your Home screen.
Frequently asked questions
How does the rrsp vs tfsa calculator decide which is ahead?
It grows the money in each account, takes the tax rate on withdrawal off the RRSP, adds the refund if you reinvest it and compares the two totals.
When is an RRSP better than a TFSA?
When your tax rate on withdrawal is lower than your rate now. They tie when the rates are equal, and the TFSA is better when the rate on withdrawal is higher.
What are the 2026 contribution limits?
The CRA limits page lists 33,810 dollars for the RRSP dollar limit and 7,000 dollars for the TFSA dollar limit. Your own room may differ.
Does the calculator include the tax refund?
Yes. You choose whether the refund goes into a TFSA or is spent.
Is the comparison an official CRA figure?
No. The CRA pages give the rules but no comparison formula, so the working is our own and uses flat marginal rates.
Sources
- Canada Revenue Agency: MP, DB, RRSP, DPSP, ALDA, TFSA limits, YMPE and the YAMPE (2026-10-28)
- Canada Revenue Agency: How contributions affect your RRSP deduction limit
- Canada Revenue Agency: T4040 RRSPs and Other Registered Plans for Retirement, Chapter 5
- Canada Revenue Agency: What is a TFSA (2026-09-17)
- Canada Revenue Agency: Withdrawing from a TFSA (2026-02-20)
Was this tool helpful?
What went wrong?
We only receive the reason you pick, never what you typed into the tool.
Thanks for your feedback.