Saved

Press the star next to a tool's name to save it.

All my tools

Rent vs Buy Calculator

Enter the home price, the rent and how long you plan to stay, and this rent vs buy calculator shows whether buying or renting leaves you better off.

Restored your last values ·

Prefilled percentages are typical US assumptions, not forecasts. Replace them with figures for your area, including closing costs in buying costs and property tax, insurance and HOA fees in upkeep.

–

Enter the home price and rent to compare.

See full result

A rent vs buy calculator helps you decide whether to keep renting or to buy a home by comparing where each choice leaves you financially. Enter the home price, the rent for a similar home and how long you plan to stay, and this rent vs buy calculator works through every month of the period. It shows how much wealth a buyer and a renter would each have at the end, and whether buying catches up within the time you have in mind.

How the rent vs buy calculator works

A fair comparison has to treat both people equally, so the calculator assumes that each one spends the same amount every month. Whoever has the lower housing cost invests the difference. The renter also invests the down payment and buying costs from the first day, since that money wasn't spent on a home.

  • Buyer's wealth = home value − selling costs − remaining loan + any investments.
  • Renter's wealth = invested down payment and buying costs + invested monthly savings.
  • Buying catches up in the first year that the buyer's wealth equals or passes the renter's.

How to use this rent vs buy calculator

  1. Enter the home price and the monthly rent for a comparable home.
  2. Check the loan details: down payment, rate and term.
  3. Enter how many years you will stay. This is often the most important number of all.
  4. Adjust the assumptions for buying and selling costs, upkeep, price growth, rent increases and investment returns.
  5. Press Compare.

Rent vs buy example

Take a $400,000 home that would rent for $2,000 a month, with 20% down and a 30-year fixed loan at 6.5%. Assume 3% closing costs to buy, 6% to sell (mostly agent fees), 2% a year for property tax, insurance and upkeep, 3% yearly price growth and rent increases, and 7% investment returns. The monthly mortgage payment is about $2,023 and the upfront cost $92,000. After 10 years, the home is worth about $537,567 with $271,284 still owed. The buyer's total is about $234,029 and the renter's about $271,493, so on these assumptions renting leaves you ahead by about $37,464. If the same home rented for $2,200 a month, buying would come out just ahead, by about $1,115. Small changes like this can reverse the result, which is exactly why it helps to try your own figures.

What matters most

  • How long you stay. Buying and selling costs are large, and they need years to be spread out and recovered.
  • The ratio of price to rent. Where homes are very expensive relative to rents, renting tends to look better.
  • Home price growth compared with investment returns. A small change in either can swing the answer.
  • The interest rate. A lower rate makes buying cheaper month by month.
  • Your discipline. The renter only comes out ahead if the money saved really is invested.

Using local numbers for your area

Prices and rents vary hugely across the US, from high-cost metros such as San Francisco, New York and Boston to more affordable markets in much of the Midwest and South, so a single rule of thumb is rarely reliable. Enter the actual asking price and the actual rent of similar homes in the neighborhood you want. Check your county's property tax rate, homeowners insurance and any HOA fees for the upkeep figure, and ask a lender for typical closing costs. The calculator doesn't hold any local data of its own, so your results are only as good as the numbers you enter.

What the numbers can't tell you

Money isn't the only part of this decision. Owning a home brings stability, freedom to make changes and the feeling that the place is yours, but it also ties you to one location and leaves you responsible for repairs. Renting gives you flexibility to move for work or family, and it leaves your savings available for other goals, but your landlord can raise the rent or decide to sell. Consider how settled your job and family plans are, then use the numbers as one input among several.

How to test your assumptions

Run the comparison several times. First change only the years you will stay, and note where the answer flips. Next lower the home price growth by a point or two, and then lower the investment return in the same way. If buying still comes out ahead across a range of cautious assumptions, you can feel more confident in that choice. The same goes for renting.

Why the two sides start so far apart

Buying involves a large payment on the first day, and part of that money, such as closing costs, doesn't come back when you sell. The renter's savings begin compounding immediately. That head start explains why buying often looks worse over short periods and better over long ones, particularly once the rent has risen for a number of years while the loan payment has stayed level.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing the rent only with the mortgage payment. A home also has upkeep, taxes and large one-time costs.
  • Forgetting the return on the down payment. That money could have been invested.
  • Assuming prices will always rise quickly. Test a slower rate too.
  • Comparing different homes. Use the rent for a home like the one you would buy.

Find a sensible budget with the home affordability calculator, work out payments with the mortgage calculator, and see how savings can grow with the compound interest calculator.

What next

Use this often? Add Rent vs Buy to your Home screen.

Frequently asked questions

How does the rent vs buy calculator work?

It follows both a buyer and a renter month by month, invests whatever each one saves, and compares their wealth at the end.

Is it better to rent or buy a home?

It depends on the home price, the rent, how long you stay and how your money would otherwise grow. Try your own figures.

How long should I stay for buying to make sense?

Buying and selling costs take years to recover. The calculator shows when buying catches up on your figures.

Does the calculator include closing costs?

Yes. Enter them as the buying costs percentage, along with other upfront charges such as points or a home inspection.

Does it include tax benefits?

No. Tax effects depend on your situation, so they are not included.

What went wrong?

We only receive the reason you pick, never what you typed into the tool.

Thanks for your feedback.

More Finance Tools