Saved

Press the star next to a tool's name to save it.

All my tools

Pension Lump Sum vs Annuity Calculator

Use this pension lump sum vs annuity calculator to compare a one-off payment with a monthly pension, see the present value of the pension, the break-even point and the discount rate where the two are equal.

Restored your last values ·

%
years
%
years

Enter the lump sum offered, the monthly pension, the discount rate you could earn on the lump sum, and the number of years you expect to be paid. Add a yearly increase if the pension rises, and your age at the start to see the break-even age.

Everything is worked out in your browser. Nothing you type is sent anywhere.

–

–

Enter the lump sum, monthly pension, rate and years, then press Calculate.

See full result

This pension lump sum vs annuity calculator helps you compare two offers: a single payment now, or a monthly pension for life. It turns the stream of monthly payments into one number today, the present value, and sets it beside the lump sum. It also shows how long you must live for the pension to pay back the lump sum, and the discount rate at which the two are worth the same.

How the pension lump sum vs annuity calculator works

An annuity is a stream of fixed periodic payments, and its value can be found by discounting each payment at a chosen interest rate [2]. The present value of a future payment is what it is worth today [1]. For a level annuity paid at the end of each period, the present value is the payment times (1 minus (1 + i) to the power of minus n), divided by i, where i is the rate per period and n the number of payments [3].

This tool applies that idea month by month. If you add a yearly increase, each year's payment is raised before it is discounted, which is our own working. It then compares the total with the lump sum.

  • Present value = sum of each monthly payment divided by (1 + rate/12) raised to the month number.
  • Break-even = the months of payments needed for the plain total, with no discounting, to reach the lump sum.
  • Equal rate = the yearly discount rate at which the present value equals the lump sum, found by trial.

Worked example

You are offered $300,000 now or $1,800 a month for 25 years, and you could earn 5% a year on the lump sum. The present value of the pension is about $307,908, so the pension is worth about $7,908 more. With no discounting, $1,800 a month reaches $300,000 after about 13.9 years, so at a starting age of 65 the break-even age is about 78.9. The two are equal at a discount rate of about 5.26%. If you could earn more than that, the lump sum looks better; if less, the pension does.

MeasureResult
Lump sum$300,000
Present value of pension at 5%$307,908
Break-even (no discounting)about 13.9 years
Equal discount rateabout 5.26%

Choosing the discount rate

The discount rate is the yearly return you think you could earn on the lump sum with a similar level of safety. A pension is a steady promise, so a safe rate such as a bond yield is a fair comparison. A higher rate makes the lump sum look better, because it assumes you can grow it faster. Try a few rates to see how sensitive the answer is.

What the calculator does not cover

  • Tax. A lump sum may be taxed all at once, or rolled over, and pension payments are taxed as income.
  • Survivor benefits. A pension may continue to a spouse, which is worth more.
  • Pension plan health. A lump sum removes the risk that the plan cannot pay.
  • Inflation protection. Enter a yearly increase if the pension has one.
  • Your own health. Expected years paid matter a great deal.

Thinking about the risks on each side

A lump sum gives you control. You can invest it, leave it to heirs, or spend it on a big need. But you carry the risk of poor returns and of spending too fast. A monthly pension gives a steady income that does not depend on markets, and a good one lasts as long as you do. That protection against living a long time is the main reason many people prefer it, even when the present value is close to the lump sum.

On the other side, a pension is only as safe as the plan or insurer behind it. If the plan is weak, a lump sum may be safer. A pension may also stop when you die, with nothing left for your family, unless you choose a survivor option. These points do not fit a formula, so use the calculator as one input to a wider decision.

Questions to ask the plan

  • Does the pension rise with inflation or stay flat?
  • What happens to my spouse if I die first?
  • Is the lump sum offer based on current interest rates?
  • Can the lump sum be rolled over to an IRA?
  • How is the plan insured or funded?

Using the equal rate

The equal rate is a handy summary. It is the yearly return the lump sum must earn for you to end up even with the pension over the years you entered. If you believe you can earn more than that rate with the same level of safety, the lump sum looks better. If you believe you would earn less, the pension looks better. Because pensions are guaranteed, many people accept a rate a little below what they hope to earn on the lump sum.

Common mistakes

  • Using a very high discount rate, which almost always favours the lump sum.
  • Entering the years from today instead of the years the pension will actually be paid.
  • Ignoring the survivor option on the pension.
  • Forgetting tax on a lump sum that is not rolled over.

What next

Use this often? Add Pension Lump to your Home screen.

Frequently asked questions

How does a pension lump sum vs annuity calculator decide?

It discounts each monthly payment to today and adds them up. If that present value is higher than the lump sum, the pension is worth more at your chosen rate.

What is the break-even age?

It is the age at which the total monthly payments, with no discounting, have added up to the lump sum. Beyond it, the pension has paid more.

Which discount rate should I use?

Use the yearly return you could earn on the lump sum at a similar level of risk. A safe rate is the fair choice for a guaranteed pension.

Does the calculator include tax?

No. Tax rules differ between a lump sum and a pension, so check with a tax professional.

Can a pension rise each year?

Yes. Enter a yearly increase and each year's payments are raised before they are discounted.

What went wrong?

We only receive the reason you pick, never what you typed into the tool.

Thanks for your feedback.

More Finance Tools