Saved

Press the star next to a tool's name to save it.

All my tools

Hire An Expert vs Train a Fresher Calculator

Use this hire an expert vs train a fresher calculator to compare the total cost of an experienced hire with a fresher plus training, over the same tenure.

Restored your last values ·

months
months

Enter the monthly wages of an expert and of a fresher, their one-off hiring costs, the monthly cost and length of the fresher's training, and how many months each person stays. Use one currency for every box.

Everything is worked out in your browser. Nothing you type is sent anywhere.

–

–

Enter the wages for both and the tenure, then press Calculate.

See full result

This hire an expert vs train a fresher calculator compares the total cost of hiring an experienced person with the cost of hiring a fresher and training them. Enter the wages, the hiring costs, the training cost and the tenure, and it shows which option costs more and by how much.

How to use the hire an expert vs train a fresher calculator

  1. Enter the expert's monthly wages and one-off hiring cost.
  2. Enter the fresher's monthly wages and hiring cost.
  3. Add the training cost per month and the training period.
  4. Enter the tenure in months and press Calculate.

The idea

An expert needs little training but asks for a higher salary. A fresher costs less each month but needs training before they are fully useful. Hiring has costs beyond the salary: Wikipedia describes cost per hire as a metric that reflects the cost of a new employee, and notes that it does not always reflect lost productivity [1]. The cost formula for each person below is our own simple model. The calculator puts both on the same footing, a total cost over the same tenure, so that you can see the difference in one figure.

The cost of the expert

The cost of the expert is the wages times the tenure plus the hiring cost. For wages of 8,000 a month over 12 months, with a hiring cost of 4,000, that is 8,000 × 12 + 4,000, which is 100,000. The model assumes that the expert needs no training, so there is no training term. If you do expect to train an expert, add that cost to the hiring cost.

The cost of the fresher

The cost of the fresher is the wages times the tenure, plus the hiring cost, plus the training cost per month times the training period. With wages of 4,000, a hiring cost of 2,000 and training of 1,500 a month for 3 months, over 12 months, that is 48,000 + 2,000 + 4,500, which is 54,500. The formula pays full wages during training, and the calculator does the same.

Reading the result

In that example the expert costs 45,500 more over the year, which is about 8,333 a month against 4,542 for the fresher. All these numbers are our own. The calculator shows the two totals, which one is higher and the difference, so you can compare them with the value that each person would add.

Training cost

The training cost is a monthly amount. It can include a trainer's time, courses and materials. Lost billable hours can count as a training cost too. That is lost income and not a bill, so you must put a money value on it yourself and include it in the monthly training cost. The tool takes the number as you give it.

Tenure

The tenure is the number of months that each person stays, and it is the same for both. A longer tenure favours the person with the lower monthly wage, as a one-off hiring cost is spread over more months. A short tenure favours the option with the smaller one-off cost. The tool gives the cost per month of tenure for each option, so you can compare them at any length.

When the cheaper option changes

The calculator adds a result that is our own working: the month at which the cheaper option changes. It adds the hiring costs on day one and the wages and training month by month. For an expert with wages of 3,000 and a hiring cost of 4,000 against a fresher with wages of 3,500 and no extra costs, the expert is more costly at first and cheaper from month 8.

The training period

The training period cannot be longer than the tenure, and the tool shows an error if it is. A training period of zero is fine and means that no training is needed. If training is part-time, enter the cost per month as the real cost of that part-time work. In the formula, the training cost applies only for the months of the training period, and wages are paid for the whole tenure.

What it leaves out

The model compares cost and not output. An expert may do more in each month, finish sooner or make fewer mistakes, and a fresher may take months to reach the same pace. The model also assumes that both people stay for the same tenure, while in practice a fresher may stay longer, or leave after you have paid for the training. Add these factors to your decision by hand.

Using it well

Run the numbers with a short and a long tenure, and with a low and a high training cost, to see how sure the answer is. Use the same currency in every box, and enter real costs such as agency fees, recruitment adverts and the time spent on interviews, which SHRM calls a soft cost of hiring [2]. Then compare the cost difference with an estimate of what the extra output of the expert is worth to you.

Common mistakes

  • Forgetting the one-off hiring cost. It can be a large part of a short tenure.
  • Leaving out lost time as a training cost. Convert it to money first.
  • Using different tenures. The tool uses one tenure for both people.
  • Treating the lowest cost as the best choice. Output and ramp-up time matter too.

What next

Use this often? Add Hire An Expe to your Home screen.

Frequently asked questions

What is a hire an expert vs train a fresher calculator?

A calculator that compares the total cost of an experienced hire with that of a fresher plus training, over the same tenure.

How is the cost of the expert worked out?

It is the wages times the tenure plus the hiring cost.

How is the cost of the fresher worked out?

It is the wages times the tenure plus the hiring cost plus the monthly training cost times the training period.

Does the calculator include the value of the work?

No. It compares cost only, and does not include output, ramp-up time or staff leaving early.

Why does a longer tenure help the cheaper monthly wage?

The one-off hiring and training costs are spread over more months, so the monthly wage matters more.

What went wrong?

We only receive the reason you pick, never what you typed into the tool.

Thanks for your feedback.

More Office & Productivity Tools