A flat rate vs effective interest rate calculator shows what a flat quote really costs. A flat rate charges interest on the full loan for the whole term, but you repay the loan month by month, so the true yearly cost is higher. Enter the loan, the flat rate and the number of monthly instalments to see the effective interest rate next to it.
How to use the flat rate vs effective interest rate calculator
- Enter the loan amount, in any currency.
- Enter the flat rate a year, for example the rate on a car loan advertisement.
- Enter the term in months.
- Press Calculate and compare the effective rate with the flat rate.
Why the two rates differ
Standard Chartered Singapore explains that a flat rate is worked out as if the amount financed stayed the same for the whole loan. It then points out that the amount financed shrinks as you pay, so the effective interest rate is higher than the flat or applied rate [1]. In plain terms, you pay interest on the full amount in month sixty even though you have almost repaid it by then.
The bank example we reproduce
The Standard Chartered page gives a loan of S$50,000 at a flat rate of 2.78 percent over five years. The interest is 2.78 percent of S$50,000 for five years, which is S$6,950, and the monthly instalment is S$50,000 plus S$6,950, divided by 60, or S$949.17 [1]. The page states an effective interest rate of 5.24 percent for this loan [1]. This calculator gives 5.24 percent as well, which is how we checked it.
The steps behind the result
First the interest is the loan times the flat rate times the years. The instalment is the loan plus the interest, divided by the number of months. Then we look for the monthly rate at which these instalments, discounted back, are worth exactly the amount you borrowed. Multiplying that monthly rate by 12 gives the effective rate. The method is our own working, tested on the bank example above.
How we find the monthly rate
There is no closed formula for the rate, so the page searches for it by repeated halving. It starts with a range from zero to 100 percent a month and narrows it two hundred times, which is far more than needed. The result does not depend on a starting guess, and it always finds the one rate that fits.
The ratio to the flat rate
The calculator also shows how many times larger the effective rate is than the flat rate. For the bank example it is 1.89. Our own working with other loans gives 1.89 for S$100,000 at 3 percent over 24 months and 1.90 for S$30,000 at 2.5 percent over 36 months. A 12-month loan at a 12 percent flat rate has an effective rate near 21.46 percent, a ratio of 1.79. The ratio is not a rule, only a check that the result is sensible.
A second way to say the annual rate
Banks that quote an effective rate generally multiply the monthly rate by 12, and so does this page. If the monthly rate is compounded for twelve months you get a slightly higher effective annual rate, which is 5.3721 percent for the bank example. We show it as a separate figure and label it as our own working, because it is not the number the bank states.
What a bank must tell you
A written reply from Singapore's Ministry of Energy, Trade and Industry, which was formerly the Ministry of Trade and Industry, says that lenders must give the effective interest rate in writing before a hire-purchase agreement under the Hire Purchase Act. It also says that banks are expected to show it in loan advertisements under the Association of Banks in Singapore advertising code [2]. The reply does not define the rate or give a formula, which is why we explain the method ourselves.
Fees and other charges
The calculator looks only at the interest. If a lender adds an administration fee, a processing fee or insurance that is financed, the true cost is higher than the figure here. Some lenders also compute interest from the day of the loan, not from the first instalment. Use the effective rate printed in your own loan document for the final comparison.
Using it for any currency
Nothing in the formula depends on a currency, so the calculator works for dollars, rupees or rand. The examples come from Singapore because that is where the bank figures were found. The same method applies to any loan that is quoted as a flat rate with equal monthly instalments.
When a flat rate is not the right comparison
If a lender quotes an interest rate on the reducing balance, that rate is already close to an effective rate, and you should not convert it again. The flat quote is the one that hides cost, so this page is meant for flat quotes only.
Common mistakes
- Comparing a flat rate with a reducing rate. They are not the same thing. Convert the flat rate first.
- Entering the term in years. The term box takes months.
- Ignoring fees. The result covers interest only, so add fees by hand.
- Trusting the page over the loan document. The lender's stated effective rate is the one that counts.
What next
Use this often? Add Flat Rate vs to your Home screen.
Frequently asked questions
What does the flat rate vs effective interest rate calculator show?
It shows the interest, the monthly instalment and the effective yearly rate that matches a flat rate quote, so you can compare loans fairly.
Why is the effective rate higher than the flat rate?
The flat rate is charged on the full loan for the whole term, but you repay the balance each month, so the true cost per year on what you still owe is higher.
How is the effective rate found?
The page finds the monthly rate that makes all instalments worth the loan amount today, then multiplies by 12. For a 50,000 loan at 2.78 percent over 60 months it gives 5.24 percent.
Does the result include fees?
No. Only interest is modelled, so processing fees, insurance and other charges are extra.
Can I use it outside Singapore?
Yes. The method works for any currency and any loan with equal monthly instalments quoted at a flat rate.
Sources
Was this tool helpful?
What went wrong?
We only receive the reason you pick, never what you typed into the tool.
Thanks for your feedback.