A cell phone plan calculator compares the cost of buying a phone outright and paying a cheaper monthly bill with the cost of a carrier plan that includes the phone in a higher monthly bill. Enter the number of months, the price of the phone and the two monthly bills, and the calculator gives the total cost of each way and tells you which is cheaper. It is a simple total-cost comparison, the same idea as total cost of ownership, which adds the cost of acquiring something to its running costs and is used to compare options. [1] It runs in your browser and nothing you enter is sent anywhere.
How to use the cell phone plan calculator
- Enter the number of months you want to compare, such as the length of the contract.
- Enter the price of the phone if you buy it outright.
- Enter the monthly bill with your own phone and the monthly bill on the carrier plan.
- Press Compare the costs.
The two formulas
There are two simple formulas, and they are our own working. If you buy the phone outright, the total cost is the price of the phone plus the monthly bill times the number of months. If you use a carrier plan that includes the phone, the total cost is the monthly bill times the number of months. In the second case the monthly bill includes the installments for the phone. The cheaper way is the one with the lower total over the time you chose.
Worked example
Our example is a phone of 800 dollars, a period of 24 months, a carrier bill of 50 dollars a month and a bill of 20 dollars a month if you bring your own phone. Buying the phone outright costs 800 plus 20 times 24, which is 1,280 dollars. The carrier plan costs 50 times 24, which is 1,200 dollars. Over 24 months, the carrier plan is cheaper by 80 dollars in this simple comparison. The calculator does not model interest on the money that you would otherwise save, so it leaves that out.
The contract length
Treat the contract length as the period after which you replace the phone. If you keep a phone for longer than the contract, buying it outright becomes better, since you stop paying for the phone after the first period. Try a longer time in the calculator to see when buying overtakes the plan.
What is not included
The calculator leaves out repair costs, taxes, activation fees, insurance, trade-in values and the interest that a carrier may charge. If your plan has any of these, add them to the monthly bill or to the price before you enter them. A phone that you can sell at the end has a value that reduces the true cost.
Other things to compare
The monthly bill also depends on the data and the calls that you use. Use our data usage calculator to find how much data you need, then research the features and costs of several plans and compare them side by side. [2] The cheapest plan on paper is not the best if it does not give what you need.
Reading the result
The calculator shows the total cost of each option, the difference between them and a message saying which is cheaper. The difference is the amount you save over the months you chose, by picking the cheaper way. If the difference is small, other things, such as the quality of the network and the flexibility to change plan, may matter more than the money.
Finding the break-even time
You can find the number of months at which the two options cost the same by trying different values for the months. The outright option has a fixed start cost of the phone, and then a lower monthly bill, so it falls behind at first and catches up later. In our example, the difference in the monthly bill is 30 dollars, and the phone costs 800 dollars, so buying outright overtakes the carrier plan after about 27 months, which is 800 divided by 30.
Choosing the time to compare
The result depends on how long you keep the phone. Many people replace a phone every two or three years, so 24 or 36 months is a fair time to compare. If you tend to keep a phone for four years, enter 48 months and see the effect. A longer time makes buying outright look better, because the cost of the phone is paid once while the carrier's monthly premium goes on every month.
Checking the offers
Phone offers often include trade-in credits, free months or discounts that run for a limited time. To include them, lower the monthly bill by the average value of the discount over the contract, or lower the price of the phone by the credit. Then run the calculator again. This gives a fairer comparison than the headline price.
Common mistakes
- Putting the phone cost into both bills. The own-phone bill has no phone payment.
- Comparing different lengths. Use the same months for both.
- Forgetting the fees. Add activation and insurance.
- Ignoring what you need. Compare plans with the same data.
What next
Use this often? Add Cell Phone P to your Home screen.
Frequently asked questions
What is a cell phone plan calculator?
A tool that compares the total cost of buying a phone yourself with a carrier plan that includes the phone.
How is the cost of buying outright worked out?
Phone price + monthly bill × months.
How is the carrier plan cost worked out?
Monthly bill × months, since the bill includes the phone installments.
Which is cheaper in the worked example?
With an 800 dollar phone over 24 months, buying costs 1,280 dollars and the carrier plan 1,200 dollars in the simple comparison.
Does it include repairs?
No. Repair costs are not included.
Sources
Was this tool helpful?
What went wrong?
We only receive the reason you pick, never what you typed into the tool.
Thanks for your feedback.