A books vs ebooks calculator compares the carbon footprint of reading on paper with reading on an e-reader, a tablet or a smartphone. Enter how many books, magazines and newspapers you read, and for how many years you would use the device, and it shows which choice emits less carbon dioxide and how many books it takes to break even.
How to use the books vs ebooks calculator
- Choose US or metric units.
- Enter the paper books you read per year, and magazines and newspapers if you read them.
- Choose the device and the years you would use it.
- Press Calculate.
What the calculator compares
The calculator sets the carbon dioxide made by producing paper reading material against the carbon dioxide made by producing one reading device. The footprint figures are the tool's own planning figures, because published studies differ widely and we found no single primary source that gives every figure for e-readers, tablets, phones, books, magazines and newspapers. A Cleantech Group study is reported to have found that about 22½ e-books pay back an e-reader's production and power use [1]. For a tablet used only as an e-reader, another study puts the threshold at roughly 13 to 30, on average 20, university textbooks [2], and a further estimate says an e-reader's lifetime footprint equals that of 30 to 70 paper books [3]. The way we combine them is our own working, and we say so wherever it matters.
The footprints used
The tool uses a production footprint of 168 kilograms of carbon dioxide for an e-reader, 130 for a tablet and 55 for a smartphone. For paper, it uses 7.46 kilograms for a book, 0.95 for a magazine and 0.62 for a newspaper. These are planning figures, and the sources above show how widely such estimates vary, so treat every number as an average.
What is left out
We ignore charging, which we assume is small next to the energy used to make the device; this is a simplifying assumption of ours. We do the same. The calculator also leaves out library books, second-hand books, sharing a device in a family, the electricity grid you use, and the end of life of the device. Each of these can change the answer, and none is in the calculation.
Our way of combining them
Paper total: for each year, books times 7.46 plus magazines times 0.95 plus newspapers times 0.62, and then times the number of years. This is our own working. The device total is its production footprint, counted once. The difference between the two tells you which choice is lower. We do not spread the device's footprint over its life, since we have no source for how to do so, but the number of years you use it sets the amount of paper that it replaces.
A worked example
Say you read 20 books and 12 magazines a year, and use an e-reader for 4 years. The paper footprint is (20 × 7.46 + 12 × 0.95) × 4 = 642.4 kilograms. The e-reader is 168 kilograms, so it saves 474.4 kilograms of carbon dioxide. This is our own arithmetic. In US mode, the result is shown in pounds first: 1,416 pounds for paper and 370 for the e-reader.
When paper wins
Read only 20 books in one year, and the paper footprint is 149.2 kilograms, which is below the 168 kilograms of an e-reader. So paper comes out 18.8 kilograms lower, and the calculator says that the device has not paid back its production footprint. The picture changes with time or with volume. A smartphone, which you may own already, has a smaller figure of 55 kilograms, and it breaks even after about seven books.
The break-even point
The calculator gives the break-even in two ways. The first is the number of books over the whole period that give a footprint equal to the device, after taking away your magazines and newspapers. For the e-reader and books alone, that is 168 ÷ 7.46, or about 22.5 books, which is our own division of the two figures. The second is the time it takes your yearly paper reading to match the device's footprint, which was 1.05 years in the example.
Trees
The tool uses the US EPA figure for an urban tree grown for 10 years, about 0.060 metric ton of carbon dioxide a year, which is 60 kilograms or about 132 pounds [4]. When the device comes out lower, the calculator divides the saving by this figure to give the number of tree-years that it equals: 7.9 in the example. Trees of other kinds, ages and places absorb different amounts, so use the number as a way to picture the amount, not as a forest plan.
Which device to choose
Choose the device that you would really buy, or the one that you already own. If you already have a smartphone or a tablet that you would use for other purposes anyway, the footprint of reading on it is smaller than the figure used here, which counts the full production. The tool counts it in full. If you have an e-reader, the more you read on it, the better it does against paper.
Using the result
Use the answer as a rough guide. The footprints are averages, and your own habits matter more than the third decimal of any number. If you read a lot, a device is likely to win. If you read a few books a year, paper, especially borrowed or second-hand paper, is likely to be as good. Change the years and the number of books to see where the balance tips.
Common mistakes
- Forgetting the years. The device is used over several years, and so is the paper that it replaces.
- Counting a device you already own. Its footprint is already spent.
- Ignoring library books. They are not in the calculation.
- Reading the answer as exact. The footprints are averages.
What next
Use this often? Add Books vs Ebo to your Home screen.
Frequently asked questions
What is a books vs ebooks calculator?
A tool that compares the carbon footprint of reading on paper with reading on a device.
How much carbon does an e-reader make?
The tool uses 168 kilograms of carbon dioxide for an e-reader, 130 for a tablet and 55 for a smartphone, as planning figures.
How much carbon does a paper book make?
The tool uses 7.46 kilograms for a book, 0.95 for a magazine and 0.62 for a newspaper, as planning figures.
How many books does it take for an e-reader to break even?
About 22.5 books on the tool's figures, which is 168 divided by 7.46. Magazines and newspapers lower the number.
Does the calculator include charging?
No. The tool ignores charging, which it assumes is small next to the energy of making the device.
Sources
Was this tool helpful?
What went wrong?
We only receive the reason you pick, never what you typed into the tool.
Thanks for your feedback.