A 3d printer buy vs outsource calculator compares what it costs to buy a printer and make your models, with what it costs to pay a print service to make them. Enter your prices and the number of models. You get both totals, the cheaper choice and the number of models at which a printer pays for itself.
How to use the 3d printer buy vs outsource calculator
- Choose US or metric units.
- Enter the printer price and any extras, and the number of models.
- Enter the filament, power, print time and electricity price for one model.
- Enter what a service charges for one model, then press Calculate.
What the calculator compares
The question is simple: for the number of models you need, is it cheaper to buy a printer or to pay for prints? The calculator takes the inputs you would expect, such as printer price, extras, filament, electricity, the price a service charges, the number of models and shipping. It then adds up each route and compares them. The way the totals are built and the break-even rule are our own working, resting on two standard ideas that we cite below: energy is power multiplied by time, and a break-even point is reached when the saving on each unit has covered the fixed cost.
The cost of filament
Filament cost per model is the mass of filament that the model uses, multiplied by the price of filament per unit of mass. This is our own working, and it is plain multiplication. A slicer program normally reports the mass of filament for a model, so this calculator asks for that mass directly, in grams or ounces, and multiplies the mass in kilograms by the price per kilogram. It does not need a density or a diameter.
The cost of electricity
A kilowatt hour is the energy of one kilowatt sustained for one hour, so kilowatt hours are the product of power and time [3]. Virginia Cooperative Extension gives the same method for a device: wattage times hours used, divided by 1,000, gives kilowatt hours, and the kilowatt hours multiplied by your utility's rate per kilowatt hour give the cost [2]. For a printer of 120 watts that runs four hours, the energy is 0.12 × 4 = 0.48 kilowatt hours, which at $0.15 costs about 7 cents.
Our totals
The cost of one model made at home is the filament plus the electricity. The total to buy is the printer, the extras, the models times that cost, and any design fee. The total to outsource is the models times the service price, plus shipping and the design fee. These sums are our own working, and they are labelled as such. The design fee counts on both sides, so it does not change which choice is cheaper.
A worked example
Take a printer at $300 with $50 of extras, 20 models of 150 grams, filament at $20 a kilogram, 120 watts for four hours at $0.15, and a service at $25 a model with $8 shipping. A model costs $3.00 of filament and $0.07 of power. Buying costs $350 plus 20 × $3.07, or $411.44. Outsourcing costs $500 plus $8, or $508.00. Buying is cheaper by $96.56.
The break-even point
The break-even point is the level at which a business has recovered all its variable and fixed costs, and in units it is total fixed costs divided by the contribution margin per unit, which is the sales price less the variable cost per unit [1]. Here the printer and the extras are the fixed cost, and each model that you print yourself saves you the service price less your own cost for it. The break-even number of models is therefore the printer and the extras divided by that saving, here $350 ÷ ($25 − $3.07), or 15.96, which rounds up to 16 models. Applying the rule to this choice is our own working. Shipping is left out of it. Below 16 models, outsourcing wins.
Where the printer never pays back
If the service charges no more than you pay to print a model at home, the saving per model is zero or negative, and the printer never pays itself back at those prices. The calculator then says so in place of showing a break-even. That can happen with a small, quick model and cheap bulk prints. It is also a reminder to check your own costs, as electricity and filament are small but not zero.
US and metric units
In US mode, enter the filament in ounces and its price in dollars a pound, as many spools are sold. The calculator converts to grams and kilograms, at 28.3495 grams to the ounce and 2.2046 pounds to the kilogram, our own conversions. A model of 5.3 ounces at $9 a pound costs about $2.98 of filament, close to the metric example. The logic is the same in both.
What the totals leave out
Real use has more costs. Prints fail, which wastes filament and time. The nozzle, bed and parts wear out. You spend hours designing, slicing and finishing, and a service delivers a finished part. A printer may also keep part of its price when you sell it, and a second-hand model may cost less. We do not include these, so add them to the extras or the per-model cost if you can.
How to use the answer
Run the calculator for the number of models you expect over the life of the printer, not for one job. A hobby of a few models a year seldom pays back a printer, while regular use does. Run it again with a higher service price, and with a higher electricity cost, to see how sensitive the answer is. If the result is close, the extra convenience of printing at home, or of receiving a finished part, may decide it. The totals are our own working, so treat them as a guide.
Common mistakes
- Forgetting failed prints. Add a margin to the filament.
- Leaving out your time. A printer needs hours of work.
- Using the weight with supports and waste. Use the slicer's total mass.
- Comparing one model only. The printer cost is shared across many.
What next
Use this often? Add 3D Printer B to your Home screen.
Frequently asked questions
What is a 3d printer buy vs outsource calculator?
A tool that compares the total cost of making your models on a printer you buy with the cost of paying a print service.
How is the cost of one print worked out?
The filament mass times its price per kilogram, plus the printer power times the print time times the electricity price.
How is the break-even found?
The printer and extras divided by the saving on each model, which is the service price less your own cost.
Does the calculator include failed prints?
No. It ignores failed prints, your time, wear and the resale value, so add them to the costs.
Which formulas come from a source?
The electricity cost uses the kilowatt hour idea and the break-even uses the standard break-even rule. The totals themselves are our own working.
Sources
Was this tool helpful?
What went wrong?
We only receive the reason you pick, never what you typed into the tool.
Thanks for your feedback.